How We Compare
See how Extra Help Moving stacks up against other moving platforms. We believe in transparency — here are the facts so you can decide for yourself.
We are not a broker. Unlike most competitors, Extra Help Moving does not sit between you and your mover. Customers post service orders, and FMCSA-verified movers contact them directly with their own quotes. No middleman, no inflated fees, no surprises.
No Booking Fees
Submit a service order for free. Movers contact you directly with their quotes — no platform markups, no hidden service fees.
Talk Directly to Your Mover
Unlike brokers, we don't sit in the middle. You speak directly with the moving company — ask questions, negotiate, build trust.
FMCSA-Verified Professionals
Every mover on our platform is verified through the federal FMCSA database. You're hiring real, licensed, authorized carriers.
Side-by-Side Comparison
All data sourced from publicly available company information. Updated June 2026.
| Feature | Extra Help Moving | HireAHelper | Moving Help (U-Haul) | Bellhop | Dolly (TaskRabbit) | TaskRabbit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1992 | 2007 | 2003 | 2011 | 2014 | 2008 |
| Business Model | Direct Platform | Marketplace / Broker | Marketplace / Broker | Moving Broker | On-Demand App | General Labor Marketplace |
| Mover Fees | $49.99/mo subscription — no per-job commission | 15–29% commission per job | 15% commission per job | Contracted crews — rates set by Bellhop | Platform sets rates for "Helpers" | Taskers set own rates, but platform adds 40–70% markup to customers |
| Customer Fees | Free — movers contact you directly with quotes | Included in hourly rate | $5.95 marketplace fee (refundable with review) | Hourly rate + 10% deposit for long-distance | Algorithmic upfront pricing | Service Fee + Trust & Support Fee (significant) |
FMCSA Verified Movers | ||||||
Direct Customer–Mover Contact | ||||||
Not a Broker | ||||||
Flat Subscription (No Commission) | ||||||
Nationwide Coverage | ||||||
Long-Distance Moves | ||||||
| Damage Coverage | Mover's own insurance (FMCSA-verified) | $1,000 standard coverage | Varies by provider | Basic coverage included, FVP optional | $300 basic coverage | Limited — varies by task |
Extra Help Moving
The original creators of the moving labor industry
$49.99/mo subscription — no per-job commission
Free — movers contact you directly with quotes
HireAHelper
Online marketplace for moving labor
15–29% commission per job
Included in hourly rate
Moving Help (U-Haul)
U-Haul's moving labor marketplace
15% commission per job
$5.95 marketplace fee (refundable with review)
Bellhop
Tech-driven moving broker
Contracted crews — rates set by Bellhop
Hourly rate + 10% deposit for long-distance
Dolly (TaskRabbit)
On-demand moving & delivery (now TaskRabbit Delivery)
Platform sets rates for "Helpers"
Algorithmic upfront pricing
TaskRabbit
General-purpose task marketplace
Taskers set own rates, but platform adds 40–70% markup to customers
Service Fee + Trust & Support Fee (significant)
The Commission Math for Movers
See how much movers actually keep on each platform based on a $500 job.
Extra Help Moving
$49.99/mo flat
HireAHelper
15–29% commission
Moving Help (U-Haul)
15% commission
*Extra Help Moving movers pay $49.99/month regardless of how many jobs they complete. After just one $500 job, the subscription has already paid for itself compared to commission models.
Disclaimer: All competitor information on this page is sourced from publicly available data including company websites, press releases, and third-party review sites as of June 2026. We strive for accuracy but cannot guarantee that competitor pricing, features, or policies have not changed since our last review. Trademarks and brand names belong to their respective owners. Extra Help Moving is not affiliated with any of the companies listed above.